Do or Do Not.

“West” Into the Sunset

with 5 comments

Last night, NBC broadcast the series finale of The West Wing, and as a nice bookend before the finale, they aired the show’s pilot episode. Watching the first and last episodes of the show back-to-back really accentuated just how much the show had changed over its seven-year run, and honestly, it probably wasn’t a very fair thing to do to the series finale. The finale was good; the pilot was superb.

The biggest difference between the two episodes, to my total lack of surprise, was in the dialogue. I think we can all accept it as understood at this point that Aaron Sorkin-penned dialogue is going to be far better than dialogue written by… well, just about anybody else, and it’s certainly true that the writing in the finale is far from Sorkin-esque. As good as the last episode was, there were absolutely no truly memorable lines of dialogue, nothing that’s going to hang around in the viewer’s head later for further rumination or stick in the cultural consciousness. Certainly nothing that stuck out like President Bartlet’s “Get your fat asses out of my White House” line from the pilot (and yes, I realize that the line by itself doesn’t read all that well, but when it was delivered by Martin Sheen [1] in context, it was blistering, I’ve gotta tell you).

Watching that first episode, what really stuck out as much as the quality of the dialogue itself was the speed with which it was delivered; I’d almost forgotten how rapidly the words shot out of these characters’ mouths, as if the words themselves were coated in hot sauce and the actors needed to get them out as quickly as possible. Gilmore Girls is the only other show I know of that’s able to cram so many words into a single episode. Watching the cast deal with Sorkin’s words was always a treat, and the fact that that level of exquisite verbal gymnastics wasn’t required of them in the final episodes almost feels like a waste of their talents.

As I said a few days ago, the last few episodes certainly weren’t bad, but the finale definitely suffered in retrospect after we watched the pilot. (Thanks to the wonders of the DVR, we watched the finale before the pilot, the opposite of the order in which NBC aired them.) Those last few episodes were saved mostly by virtue of a compelling situation (peering behind the curtain at the transition between presidencies) and the abilities of the still-excellent cast. The finale was able to provide a couple of nice moments between characters (especially nice was the moment between Bartlet and Charlie, and the return of one particularly significant bit of WW mythology), but I was left feeling that I didn’t get the closure I needed with most of these characters.

Y’know, this might seem a funny thing to say about a show that won the Emmy award for Best Drama four times, but what was really missing from those last few Sorkin-free episodes I saw was the sense of fun that the show had in the early years. Even at its talkiest and most intense, The West Wing still had a well-defined sense of humor when Sorkin was at the helm, and that humor was largely lacking as the show ended its run. Even Josh Lyman (the brilliant Bradley Whitford — more on him later today), who was always the funniest, most glib and most sarcastic of the main cast, spent too much time being overworked, tense and morose to show much wit. (Not even finally bagging Donna after all that time was able to bring his funny back.) I think that as much as anything else, it was the loss of that ability to effectively straddle the line between comedy and drama (an oh-so-Sorkin trait) that made The West Wing a lesser show at the end than it was at the beginning.

At its best, The West Wing presented a hyper-intelligent, idealistic, complicated, sometimes fractious group of people who desperately believed in the righteousness of what they were doing and sincerely believed their government could help make the lives of Americans — all Americans — better. They didn’t always make the best choices, but I never doubted that that their intentions were in the right place. The fact that the show managed this feat during a time when our real presidential administration seemed to be interested in helping only itself and the wealthiest one percent of the country made The West Wing that much more poignant to me — and pushed the show beyond comedy or drama and into fantasy instead. Many times I wished these were the people really running our country and that the White House’s current occupants were nothing but characters in a horror story.

[1] At some point in the last seven years, Martin Sheen/Jed Bartlet seems to have turned into a shorter version of my father. Though I’m not sure the Republican in him would much appreciate the comparison.

Written by Allen

May 15th, 2006 at 4:13 pm

Posted in TV

Tagged with

5 Responses to '“West” Into the Sunset'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to '“West” Into the Sunset'.

  1. I had the same take on the conclusion.

    It would have rocked if it had been Sorkin. But there were just some missed moments, you know? Like when Bartlett’s watching the inauguration, and he’s just standing there, mouth agape a little, as if he’s Reagan trying to remember something he should have done. SHould have been tighter. Should have been funnier. Should have been more emotional. Should have been Sorkin.

    And what’s up with Rob Lowe? I wish he looked a little, just a LITTLE less like he’s joined the ranks of the vampiric undead, traded in his soul and boyish cuteness for preternatural George-Hamilton-like Hollywood artifice.

    Terry

    15 May 06 at 4:43 pm

  2. I didn’t watch a large portion of West Wing, but what I did watch I really enjoyed. However, I will make the same offer to you that I have to many of my friends: if you’re jonesing for more Aaron Sorkin, allow me to wave a couple of episodes of SportsNight under your nose. Criminally, it only ran for a season and a half, but it’s all the comic timing and pacing and dialogue that you love from West Wing, only even more raw and viciously delivered.

    If you remind me 24 hours in advance of seeing me, I’ll be happy to loan you the DVDs.

    Orion

    15 May 06 at 4:56 pm

  3. Terry: You’re dead-on about Mr. Lowe. He had the plastic look of the freshly-botoxed (nicely contrasted by his regular-but-beautiful-person look in the pilot), and he looked not at all happy about making token appearances in the two late-series episodes.

    Orion: That’s a mighty kind offer, but not necessary — I’ve already seen every episode of SportsNight. :) I don’t own the DVDs myself yet, though it’s only a matter of time. Lend those discs out to someone who hasn’t seen ‘em yet, spread the love!

    And keep your eyes peeled in this space for more Sorkiniana to come later today…

    Allen

    15 May 06 at 5:01 pm

  4. Allen, you may not OWN the DVDs for SportsNight, but you seem to have managed to… acquire them indefinitely. Are we holding them ransom for something?

    And “Sorkiniana” just sounds dirty. May I suggest a blend of “Sorkin” and “paraphenalia” :: Thus, “paraphenSorkinalia”? OR Sorkinalia? Eh, fuggit. Bring on the Sorkiniana!

    Terry

    15 May 06 at 5:30 pm

  5. What we’ve got there isn’t all of SportsNight; it’s only the first two-thirds or so. I guess I really should send those back to Timmy B. and we should buy our own copy, huh?

    “Sorkinalia” sounds too much like a holiday — which we’ll be celebrating this September! More to come in tonight’s Sorkiniana….

    Allen

    15 May 06 at 5:34 pm

Leave a Reply